Monday 25 May 2020

A question for Steven Pinker's optimism

I would love to be able to believe the message of Steven Pinker's The Better Angels of Our Nature and other works that expound a worldview of progress. But it seems to me that at present those parts of the world experiencing the strongest population and GDP growth are those with characteristics I am not in favor of. The questions I would ask would be:

  • What are the GDP and population growth rates of democracies versus non-democracies?
  • What are the GDP and population growth rates of secular societies versus those dominated by religious fundamentalism?
And given that a classification between democracy and non-democracy, and between secular and fundamental, is somewhat arbitrary given these factors are a spectrum:
  • Are countries becoming more or less democratic?
  • Are countries becoming more of less secular?

No comments: